Management of a recurrent right juvenile nasopharyngeal angiofibroma using direct tumorous puncture embolisation and a subtemporal-preauricular infratemporal fossa surgical approach
- 1 Otolaryngology, Manchester Royal Infirmary, Manchester, UK
- 2 ENT, Manchester Royal Infirmary, Manchester, UK
- 3 Interventional Radiology, Salford Royal Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Salford, UK
- 4 Neurosurgery, Salford Royal NHS Foundation Trust, Salford, UK
- Correspondence to Stefan Linton; Stefan.Linton@mft.nhs.uk
Abstract
A juvenile nasopharyngeal angiofibroma (JNA) is a benign vascular tumour that arises from the pterygopalatine fossa. It is seen near exclusively in young males though female cases have been reported. Symptoms are due to their high vascularity and mass effect. Commonly reported symptoms include: nasal obstruction, epistaxis and nasal discharge. The mainstay of treatment is surgical resection either via an endonasal endoscopic approach or open surgical resection. Preoperative embolisation has been shown to decrease intraoperative bleeding. Embolisation may be undertaken via a transarterial (TA) approach or, more recently, via direct tumorous puncture (DTP). Options for recurrent or residual disease may include revision surgery, radiotherapy or close clinical surveillance. The following case presentation describes the management of a recurrent JNA in an adult male using preoperative embolisation via a combination of TA and DTP embolisation and an open surgical resection via a subtemporal-preauricular infratemporal fossa approach.
Background
The term ‘juvenile nasopharyngeal angiofibroma (JNA)’, first coined by Friedberg1 in 1940, is a rare, benign vascular tumour arising from the pterygopalatine fossa at the aperture of the pterygoid (vidian) canal. They account for 0.05%–0.5% of all head and neck tumours.2 3 These tumours are seen to arise exclusively in men with a typical age of presentation between 14 and 25 years.4 It should be acknowledged that some tumours have been reported in the literature to have occurred in women, though very rarely.5 6 The predilection for the male sex has been explored, and strong evidence reveals a hormonal influence by the presence of androgen receptors on these tumours.7 8
Symptoms arising from JNAs are due to their high vascularity and mass effect. Common presenting symptoms include: persistent nasal obstruction (80%–90%), recurrent epistaxis (60%) and nasal discharge (23%).3 4 9 Though benign, JNAs can invade surrounding structures such as the orbit, skull base and paranasal sinuses with resultant symptoms such as diplopia, headaches and facial deformity. Diagnosis is made clinically and radiologically, given their characteristic features on imaging. Biopsy should be avoided due to the high vascular nature of these tumours.
The mainstay of treatment for JNAs is surgical resection with complete excision being the goal. Due to the high vascular nature of these tumours and potential for significant blood loss intraoperatively, preoperative angioembolisation has become standard practice as an adjunct to reduce intraoperative bleeding. If tumour feeding vessels cannot be safely ligated via transarterial (TA) embolisation then direct tumorous puncture (DTP) embolisation should be considered.2
Surgical resection can either be carried out via an open/external approach or via an endonasal endoscopic or a combination of both depending on tumour size, extension as well as surgeon experience. Management of residual disease include further surgical resection, radiotherapy or simply close clinical monitoring, thereby reducing the risk of morbidity from multiple surgical procedures.10
This case report highlights the use of intratumorous embolisation and an open surgical approach using a subtemporal-preauricular infratemporal fossa approach for a recurrent JNA in an adult male.
Case presentation
An adult male in his 20s was admitted to the hospital for an elective resection of a recurrent right-sided skull base JNA. His previous operation was carried out 2.5 years prior and consisted of an endoscopic endonasal resection of the medial aspect of the skull base JNA after preoperative embolisation. The patient had previously underwent two prior endoscopic resections in Belgium. He was originally referred to the skull base team at our institution 3 years prior for further management of the recurrent JNA, after surveillance CT imaging showed interim growth of the tumour. At that time, he only complained of decrease sensation to the right side of his face in the distribution of the maxillary and mandibular division of the trigeminal nerve (V2 and V3). The patient had no perioperative or postoperative complications from the previous procedure. This operation would be open surgery and would consist of a lateral sub-temporal approach with orbital and zygomatic osteotomies as well as a coronoid osteotomy to excise the infratemporal and middle fossa component of the JNA (see figure 1A,B). Surgery specific risk factors were explained to the patient and included: facial nerve injury, trismus, facial numbness, diplopia, blindness, cerebrospinal fluid leak and stroke. Further embolisation of the tumour’s feeding vessels was planned preoperatively. Originally, this procedure was planned to occur 12 months after the previous operation; however, this was postponed due to the events of the COVID-19 pandemic. Specifically, as the patient would not be allowed visitors during his hospitalisation due to the government mandated restrictions,therefore, he chose to have this procedure done when restrictions were lifted.
Postcontrast MRI of the neck T1 image showing the infratemporal component (A) and middle fossa component (B) (blue arrows) of the recurrent juvenile nasopharyngeal angiofibroma.
In hospital, 5 days prior to his surgery, he underwent intratumorous embolisation using precipitating hydrophobic injectable liquid as well as coil embolisation of the superficial temporal artery. The ascending pharyngeal artery was also meant to be a target but was deemed too high risk for cranial nerve 9–11 deficits. Postembolisation, the patient remained well. In preparation for surgery, four units of packed blood cells were requested, and the cell salvage device was reserved for the operation. Preoperative blood investigations were normal.
Treatment
General anaesthesia was performed in the standard fashion. Monitoring included: blood pressure, pulse oximetry, ECG, arterial blood pressure as well as facial nerve monitoring. Incisions were marked, and the patient was prepped in the usual fashion. A right frontotemporal incision was made and extended inferiorly preauricularly into the cervical region two finger breadths below the angle of the mandible. The platysma and the superficial musculoaponeurotic system were raised in continuity with the subgaleal scalp flap. The main trunk of the facial nerve was identified and protected. The carotid bifurcation was located, and the external carotid artery was identified and protected with vascular loops. This allowed for vascular control inferiorly if excessive bleeding was encountered. Soft tissue and muscle layers were dissected off the orbital rim and zygomatic arch in preparation for the bony cuts. Orbitozygomatic osteotomies were then made. The temporalis and masseter muscles were reflected off their bony attachments allowing for a coronoidectomy. Now, with adequate exposure of the tumour, resection proceeded in an extracapsular fashion using bipolar dissection from a lateral to medial fashion. The tumour had eroded into the middle cranial fossa floor with extension medially to the foramen rotundum and ovale. Inferiomedially, the tumour extended beyond the lateral pterygoid plate up to the nasopharynx and sphenoid sinus. A pterional craniotomy was deemed necessary to develop a dissection plane along the middle cranial fossa, thereby allowing for safe resection of the tumour (see figure 2). V2 and V3 were sacrificed due to gross tumorous involvement. Resection was completed en bloc, and the specimen was sent for histopathological analysis. Surrounding tissue specimens were sent for histological analysis and included tissue from: middle cranial fossa floor, pterygopalatine fossa, right sphenoid and a level 2a lymph node. Medpor temporal fossa implant was inserted and secured with screws. Bone flaps were replaced and secured using miniplates and screws. Haemostasis was achieved, and a Jackson Pratt drain was inserted into the neck wound. The surgical wound was then closed in layers. A nasogastric tube (NGT) was placed prophylactically to supplement enteral diet in the event of postoperative swallowing dysfunction. The patient was extubated and transferred to the intensive care unit (ICU). Prophylactic antibiotics consisted of a 7-day course of ceftriaxone 1.5 g intravenously once a day and metronidazole 500 mg intravenously three times a day.
Intraoperative view postexcision of the recurrent juvenile nasopharyngeal angiofibroma. (A) External carotid with vascular loops. (B) Temporalis muscle and superficial parotid lobe retracted inferiorly. (C) Temporal lobe. (D) Excised tumour bed extending into nasopharynx (floor of middle cranial fossa removed). (E) Body of mandible. (F) Orbit.
Outcome and follow-up
Postoperatively, the patient remained stable. His facial nerve was functioning normally; however, he did have weakness to the temporal branch supplying frontalis. This was expected due to traction on the nerve during the operation. He complained of hypoaesthesia to the right side of his face in the distribution of V1–V3. The patient remained on the ICU for 2 days before being transferred back to ward level care. During his ICU stay, he was noted on postoperative day 2 to have several temperature spikes; however, this was deemed as a result of postoperative surgical inflammation rather than a true postoperative infection as blood and urine cultures showed no bacterial growth. Postoperative contrast MRI of the head showed no gross tumour residuum (figure 2). However, due to postoperative tissue enhancement, it was difficult to assess for small volume tumour residuum. On the ward, he remained well and successfully had his NGT removed on postoperative day 8 after his swallowing and oral intake were deemed satisfactory by the speech and language and dietitian teams, respectively. He was discharged the same day from the hospital.
Histological analysis from the intraoperative specimens sent showed JNA tissue in all specimens except for the level 2 lymph node.
Five months postdischarge from hospital, the patient was admitted from nurse led wound clinic due to three small areas of wound dehiscence measuring (1.5×1.5 cm, 0.5×0.5 cm and 0.3 cm) along the temporal region of the wound. Exposed temporal fossa implant was noted at the deeper aspect of the dehiscence. Wound swabs taken at that time ruled out any evidence of infection. Blood laboratory investigations were normal. The rest of the clinical exam was normal aside from hypoaesthesia to the patient’s face along V2 and V3 distribution (long standing). MRI of the brain requested at this time did not show any evidence of infection within the intracranial cavity or gross tumour recurrence. After review by the neurosurgery and plastics’ team, the plan was for primary closure as a joint procedure on an elective basis. The wound was closed using a local rotational flap followed by primary closure after removal of the temporal fossa implant. He made a complete recovery and was discharged from the hospital 5 days after the operation. The temporal fossa implant cultured Staphylococcus aureus and Aspergillus fumigatus. The patient continues to be followed up at neurosurgery wound clinic.
Discussion
The surgical management of a JNA is a challenging endeavour. It is complicated by the high vascularity of the tumour, the young age of the patient as well as difficulty accessing the tumour due to the complex locoregional anatomy. These factors can lead to residual tumour being left behind, resulting in recurrence of the JNA. Tyagi et al,10 in their case series of 95 patients undergoing treatment for JNAs within a 10-year period, identified residual tumour in 18% and recurrence in 13.7% of patients. In their study, they highlighted several factors that may have led to either residual or recurrent tumour. These include the following:
-
Extension of the JNA into the pyterygoid fossa and basisphenoid.
-
Intracranial extension medial to the cavernous sinus.
-
Erosion of the clivus.
-
Feeding vessels from the internal carotid artery.
In a more recent study, Liu et al,11 in their case series of 131 patients previously treated for JNA, revealed that tumour stage and intraoperative bleeding were the main contributing factors that lead to recurrence. This is not surprising as more advance tumours would extend deeper into surrounding tissue as well as have a rich vascular supply. Understandably, excessive bleeding can blunt the view of the surgical field, making complete excision difficult. Therefore, minimising intraoperative bleeding is imperative for successful excision of a JNA. To accomplish this reduction in bleeding, preoperative tumour embolisation has become standard practice in the treatment of JNA.12 13
Preoperative JNA embolisation has been shown to be a safe, acceptable treatment adjunct to reduce intraoperative bleeding and need for postoperative blood transfusion.13 Tumour embolisation of JNAs was first recommended by Roberson et al 14 in the late 1970s, after noting a significant decrease in intraoperative bleeding in patients who were embolised versus non-embolised patients. In this study, embolisation was carried out via two techniques: (1) direct approach using large teflon catheters combined with Silastic spheres; (2) transfemoral approach using gelatin foam as the embolisation material. Since then, advancements in the endovascular field have substituted older embolic materials (eg, gelatin, silk and gelatin spheres) for particulate (polyvinyl alcohol and embospheres) and liquid (onyx and n-butyl cyanoacrylate) embolic materials. Other types of embolic materials include solid mechanical agents such as coils. Each type of embolic material has its advantages and disadvantages; therefore, selection must be considered on a case-by-case basis. For example, particulate materials are cheaper but are radiolucent requiring an increase contrast load to determine extent of tumorous embolisation. Therefore, caution should be used when using these materials in young patients as the overall contrast load can be harmful. Liquid embolic materials are expensive and more difficult to administer requiring more experienced clinicians for safe application. However, their application does not depend on the patient’s coagulation status for optimal embolisation, making them ideal for use in cases of severe coagulopathy.15 Coils produce permanent vessel occlusion and are a great choice for tumorous embolisation. As coils are coated in thrombogenic material, they are reliant on the patient’s own ability to form a clot; hence in cases of severe coagulopathy, their effectiveness may be reduced.15
Once the embolic material is chosen, the method of embolisation must be considered. TA embolisation has been the traditional method of achieving tumorous devascularisation; however, DTP has become the technique of choice for JNA embolisation for several reasons. First, unlike TA embolisation that can prove challenging due to the need to navigate tortuous feeding vessels, DTP forgoes this necessity resulting in the entire procedure taking less time as compared with TA.16 Second, TA embolisation by traditional technique can potentially lead to refluxing of embolic material and in the presence of extracranial-intracranial anastomosis can lead to a cerebrovascular accident.16 17 Finally, DTP has been shown to give higher degrees of devascularisation versus TA embolisation.18 Given these reasons, it is easy to understand why a combination of TA and DTP was chosen for preoperative embolisation in our patient. Not only does the surgical team benefit from feeding vessel ligation via TA embolisation but they also benefit from the effective devascularisation of DTP embolisation. Furthermore, during our patient’s embolisation, the ascending pharyngeal artery could not be ligated due to the high risk of glossopharyngeal nerve damage. Therefore if DTP was not carried out, intraoperative bleeding may have been significant. DTP is not without its risk and share similar complications to TA embolisation (eg, cerebral emboli or retinal artery occlusion), though the risk of distal embolisation may be less as compared with TA embolisation.18
Following on from the embolisation techniques for JNA, the different surgical approaches used to excise JNAs should be discussed. Surgical techniques for JNA excision include transnasal, transpalatal and infratemporal approaches. The chosen approach depends on several factors, some of which have been highlighted above. These include tumour location, size, locoregional extension, patient performance status, availability of specialise equipment such as ‘computer-assisted imaging systems (eg, Brain lab)’ and surgeon experience. Endonasal endoscopic techniques in combination with intraoperative assisted imaging can be used for tumours isolated to the paranasal sinuses. This approach minimises injury to surrounding soft tissue structures and is less invasive compared with open surgery. Complete excision for tumours extending laterally into the infratemporal fossa can be difficult using an endoscopic approach but not impossible. Khalifa and Ragab,19 in their prospective study, compared surgical outcomes of patients who underwent an endonasal endoscopic surgery for advance JNAs extending into the infratemporal fossa against those patients who had an open surgical approach for excision. Though the sample size was small (16 per surgical group), the results revealed that an endonasal endoscopic approach to the infratemporal fossa using an antral window was safe and effective with less blood loss compared with open surgery. However, such an approach cannot provide an adequate surgical view of the infratemporal, middle fossa and cavernous sinus regions, and therefore, an open surgical approach still remains the best option for laterally extending JNAs.
In the current case presentation, an open subtemporal-preauricular infratemporal fossa approach was felt to be the best option for complete tumorous excision given the tumour’s extension along the middle cranial fossa region of the skull base, the nasopharynx and into the infratemporal fossa. This in combination with a pterional craniotomy and coronoidectomy allowed for safe dissection along the skull base and gave adequate exposure to the infratemporal fossa. This approach has been shown to be effective for total tumour removal of JNAs with wide lateral extension. Yamada et al 20 described their outcomes of JNAs excised using this similar lateral open surgical approach. In their case series of 11 patients, they succeeded with complete tumorous removal in 10 out of 11 patients with only two patients suffering recurrence. This open surgical approach gives excellent exposure to the tumour but at risk of causing excessive blood loss. Additionally, there is a high risk of morbidity due to facial nerve dissection, osteotomies and the possible need for a craniotomy. In the same case series,20 the most common complication was trismus (11 patients) followed by facial numbness (3 patients) and facial palsy (2 patients). The patient in the current case presentation had all three symptoms postoperatively which had been expected.
Finally, management of residual and recurrent disease remains challenging. Radiotherapy has been shown in small case series to be beneficial in the treatment of recurrence.21 22 However, the long-term complications of radiotherapy to the head and neck region (eg, cataract, temporal bone osteoradionecrosis and panhypopituitarism) can be devastating. Secondary malignancy has also been reported as a serious complication of radiotherapy treatment of JNAs.23 Given such severe complications from radiotherapy, close surveillance with repeat imaging has been advocated for recurrence/residual disease in the first instance. A multidisciplinary team approach should be taken if patients become symptomatic as a result of recurrence. In the current case presentation, there is a likelihood from the pathology result that residual disease remains, and hence, it has been the decision of the managing team to monitor closely with repeat imaging in the form of MRI.
Patient’s perspective
As the stepmother of the patient in this case report, I was by his side throughout this hospitalisation. Unfortunately, his previous surgery in another hospital was unsuccessful in removing all the tumour. Originally, he was scheduled for this operation in 2020 but the pandemic hit. He had the choice of going in alone to undergo the procedure, but it was jointly decided between him and his consultant that this would affect his mental health negatively, as no visitors would be allowed and therefore it was decided to postpone the surgery till restrictions were lifted.
His recovery from his first operation seemed to take longer than this more intense surgery. He struggled in 2019 to build his stamina back up and get back on track; however, he was determined this time to get ‘back to normal’ as soon as possible.
It’s been a tough year, first waiting for the operation, and living through the after-effects’ ups and downs, which are still ongoing. This article helps shed some light on the whole ordeal he has been through this year. We as a family are wholly grateful to everyone who has been and continues to be involved in his care. The teams involved in his care have gone above and beyond to help him. They’ve put his wishes at the forefront of everything that has been decided and that’s how we have managed to get through everything so far. We are hoping he will make a full recovery soon, which looks extremely promising.
Learning points
-
The management of juvenile nasopharyngeal angiofibromas (JNAs) is complex. The mainstay of treatment is surgery. Preoperative embolisation has become standard practice and is used to decrease intraoperative bleeding.
-
Direct tumorous puncture embolisation may provide the maximum tumour devascularisation preoperatively as compared with transarterial embolisation.
-
An open subtemporal-preauricular infratemporal fossa approach gives optimal surgical access for large JNAs that extend into the infratemporal fossa, middle cranial fossa, the nasopharynx and sphenoid sinus.
-
Decisions on management of residual/recurrent disease should be decided via a multidisciplinary team approach. Options include: close surveillance with repeat imaging, revision surgery or radiotherapy.
Ethics statements
Patient consent for publication
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank the patient and his family for giving the authors permission to write up this case report and also for contributing their unique perspective to the final article.
Footnotes
-
Contributors SL wrote the main body of the article. NM contributed the images. HS reviewed the radiology portion of the discussion. OP reviewed the article.
-
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
-
Case reports provide a valuable learning resource for the scientific community and can indicate areas of interest for future research. They should not be used in isolation to guide treatment choices or public health policy.
-
Competing interests None declared.
-
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
- © BMJ Publishing Group Limited 2023. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.
References
Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer